Al Green

There's no question Al Green can still sing, and we're lucky that he's continuing to do so, but on his most recent studio album, Lay It Down, the magic flickers in and out. Green never embarrasses himself, and he has lovely vocal moments, the softly strangled tone of his voice as delicate as ever. As he's aged, however, he can't quite sustain the notes in the same way he once was able to. Green's songs have often been about salesmanship, about convincing the listener of something through his earnestness, and while he's no Shelley Levene by a long shot, the younger guests on the record (Anthony Hamilton, Corinne Bailey Rae, John Legend), although less vocally distinctive, demonstrate greater potency. Production by ?uestlove, of The Roots, is quiet and laid back, but it can seem thin when compared with Willie Mitchell's work, as on "Take Your Time," a pretty male-female duet that could use a deeper, richer sound on its instrumentation.

Too often, the strings come off stuck at the treble end of the scale, and the horns, provided by The Dap-Kings, are perhaps too willing to stay in the background rather than make Green amplify himself. One wants to be swept away by this kind of music, but the rapturous moments that necessitate closing one’s eyes are rare. Lay It Down is full of suggestions that what's being laid down is not only 11 tracks, but a burden, of sorts. If this album really is the beginning of saying goodbye, one hopes the end won't be muted so much as it is accompanied by heavenly choirs.

—Hillary Brown
06.10.08

The big question that greets listeners encountering Al Green's third Blue Note album, Lay It Down, is: what happens when you put that amazing soul-drenched voice in the hands of hip-hop producers Ahmir "?uestlove" Thompson of the Roots and James Poyser, and add a slew of superstar guests? Answer: a killer Al Green soul album. Thompson and Poyser weren't interested in straying far from the classic sound Green and producer Willie Mitchell created at Hi Records in the 1970s, but they did want to place it in a more contemporary -- albeit analog -- setting. Green cut his previous offerings for the label -- 2003's I Can't Stop and 2005's Everything's OK -- with Mitchell, and the results were good, not great, albums because Green's sound was simply re-created nostalgically. Even though Thompson and Poyser have been very creative here with their nuanced percussive, textural, and dynamic touches, Lay It Down is more of a classic-sounding Al Green record than either of its predecessors. The producers are at the core of a studio band (on drums and various analog keyboards, respectively) that also includes Mighty Clouds of Joy guitarist Chalmers "Spanky" Alford (in whose memory the album is dedicated), bassist Adam Blackstone (Jill Scott), and the Dap-Kings Horns. Lay It Down is a slow-burning, solid groover of a soul record; its dynamics and textures shift subtly and purposely to keep Green's voice at the center of its sound. If there is a flaw on the set, it's that individual tracks don't assert themselves immediately. Green, Poyser, and Thompson were going for immediacy and feel: nine of the album's 11 cuts had basic tracks done in their first session. They achieved their goal and then some -- the album feels of such an atmospheric piece and is so present that it initially comes off as a whole. That said, there is no better place to spend 45 minutes than in Lay It Down's dreamy, sensual, gritty, and tender sound world. ~ Thom Jurek, Rovi