Melodia offers a short 'n' simple version of the Vines' freewheeling sound, interspersing the fuzz-guitar freakouts that launched the band in 2001 with the measured, melodic songs that help differentiate the Vines from other members of the garage rock revival. Like 2006's Vision Valley, it's also clouded by the specter of Craig Nicholls' mental disorder, which splintered the band's lineup in 2004 and threw its ability to tour into jeopardy. Confining himself to the studio should be good for Nicholls, but the songwriter focuses on brevity rather than craft, halting most of these songs around the two-minute mark without packing them full of dense, bubblegum-punk hooks. When the band barges its way through a song like "He's a Rocker," the result recalls the glory days of Highly Evolved, when Nicholls' tendency to go bonkers on-stage was mitigated by the punky promise of his tunes. Elsewhere, Melodia offers up a handful of winsome slower numbers -- most notably the lushly harmonized "Orange Amber" and "Kara Jayne," two charming examples of Nicholls' fascination with the Beatles -- but those fleeting highlights don't replace the swagger, the snot-nosed attitude, or the crazed noise that propelled the band to platinum status several years prior. On the sunny side, those willing to branch out may also find themselves enamored with "True as the Night," the album's requisite six-minute epic that, unlike the lengthy psychedelic pop opuses that conclude the Vines' previous albums, intentionally bisects Melodia's 14-song track list. Could it be a sign that the Vines wish to emphasize their diversions from the garage rock formula as much as the formula itself? Perhaps, but Melodia is too brief to yield any real answers. ~ Andrew Leahey, All Music Guide
Melodia
03/24/2009 | Bmg Japan
All Music Guide Review
Melodia Track Listing
Melodia Notes
In an age of synths, ornate string arrangements, and electronic embellishments, the Vines continue to play straight-forward, no frills rock & roll on Melodia, their fourth full-length. Singer and guitarist Craig Nicholls snarls and scowls his way through tracks like "Braindead," "Scream," and "Get Out," like only a man who’s known the crowd-fueled, fist-pumping energy of a packed concert hall can. These are songs that ignite, full of the unabashedly snotty garage-rock-meets-post-grunge glory that sent the Vines' stunning debut, Highly Evolved, rocketing up the charts.
There's nothing superfluous about Melodia: few of the album's 14 tracks go beyond the two-and-a-half-minute mark. These are tight, tuneful songs – loud and fast rock & roll, pure and simple. Bassist Brad Heald's aggressive bass lines drive songs like "Manger," while it's the swagger in Nicholls' voice alone that brings life to "Merrygoround" and "He's A Rocker." But these tracks are tempered by the more introspective pieces, written by a man who's clearly been as inspired by Brian Wilson, John Lennon, and Ray Davies as he has Kurt Cobain. "Kara Jayne," for example, is a pretty, harmony-filled love song, and "A Girl I Knew," in which he sings, "There are things I couldn't say/There are times I feel ashamed/Marriage was a thing we had/Hurt so much that it made me mad," shows a man unafraid express emotion and admit to his own mistakes.
Melodia is a record by a band who've seen a lot since they broke into the public's consciousness, and it's a record that reflects those changes without forgetting what won them so many fans in the first place. Even as Nicholls now copes with the Asperger's Syndrome he was diagnosed with in 2004, the songs on Melodia ring as a testament to the band's talent and focus, and most of all, their dedication to making the kind of rock & roll that sticks to your ribs and stays in your head long past the actual notes have stopped ringing.
Credits of Melodia
- Rob Schnapf
- Guitar (Acoustic), Guitar (12 String), Producer, Mixing
- Doug Boehm
- Engineer, Mixing
- Daphne Chen
- Violin
- Craig Nicholls
- Guitar, Vocals, Group Member, Sleeve Art
- Hamish Rosser
- Percussion, Group Member, Drums
- Ryan Griffiths
- Guitar, Percussion, Keyboards, Group Member
- Matt Fish
- Cello
- Jason Borger
- String Arrangements
- Jason Gossman
- Mixing Assistant
- Amy Wickman
- Violin
- Jacqui Innes
- Photography
- Graham Hope
- Assistant Engineer
- Dave Bowling
- Assistant Engineer














Plus